Understanding Nutmeg Investment Alternatives: An Investors’ Guide

Nutmeg is a privately-owned UK-based company founded in 2011 and is registered as Nutmeg Saving and Investment Limited. It is an online discretionary investment management company specialising in investing in equities, corporate funds, gilts and gold on behalf of its clients. Nutmeg manages customer assets via Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) and it raised close to £30 million in November 2016 from Convoy, one of Hong Kong’s largest financial services players. But what are the Nutmeg Investment alternatives? And is Nutmeg the best choice in an unbiased broker comparison?

  • Nutmeg Investment alternatives
  • Cost break up of alternatives to Nutmeg investment
  • How safe is Nutmeg investment?
  • Customer support and robust mobile app
Stocks Highlights

Nutmeg Fees

In 2017 the company reduced its fees to beat the competition and now Nutmeg charges between 0.3%-0.95% depending on the size of the investment. Nutmeg does not charge any separate fees for set-up or for rebalancing a portfolio. There are three categories of fees: managed portfolio fees, competitor managed portfolio fees and fixed asset allocation portfolio fees, which are charged based on the investment portfolio. For example, an investment amount between £0 – £20,000 will attract 0.75% in managed portfolio fees, 0.7% in competitor managed portfolio fees and 0.45% in fixed asset allocation portfolio fees. The larger the investment amount the fewer Nutmeg fees will be paid by the client.

Ratgeberbilder Artikel Boerse

There are no charges for set-up, withdrawal or deposits, but to open an account a minimum investment of £500 is required. The fee structure is very competitive and depends on whether the client selects a fully managed portfolio or a fixed allocation portfolio. A fully managed portfolio is actively run and is more expensive (high risk and high returns) compared to fixed allocation, which has less risk associated with it. According to Nutmeg, clients investing through their portfolio services can increase their returns by 0.29% to 0.94% per year because this is the average amount they can expect to save on management fees with the company. It might look to be a small figure, but it can really add up during a long investing tenure.

Top 3 Stock Broker Comparison

1
of 10 Stock Broker Charles Stanley Direct
National fees £ 11,50
Custody fee 0,25%
Intl. fees £ 11,50
Dep. Protection 50,000 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
2
of 10 Stock Broker Fidelity
National fees £ 10,00
Custody fee 0,35%
Intl. fees £ 10,00
Dep. Protection 50,000 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
3
of 10 Stock Broker Bestinvest Brokerage
National fees £ 7,50
Custody fee 0,4%
Intl. fees £ 7,50
Dep. Protection 50,000 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.

Alternatives to Nutmeg Investment

Nutmeg is best suited to customers who want a cost-effective way to invest in financial markets but do not have the time or expertise to make their own investment choices. Also, to maximize returns, clients investing through Nutmeg should expect to invest for the long-term to see their investment grow.

Thinking more about a Nutmeg stock broker comparison – one of Nutmeg’s biggest competitors is Moneyfarm, which was launched in the UK after becoming one of the largest digital investment companies in Europe. Nutmeg charges less compared to Moneyfarm when management fees and fund charges are considered for each proposition. Moneyfarm also does not provide a pension product, so if a client wants to invest in a stocks ISA then Nutmeg is a better option. However, Nutmeg’s base management fee is relatively higher for a fully managed portfolio compared to Moneyfarm but if an investment amount is greater than £520,000 Nutmeg becomes less expensive. Also, the average underlying fees (0.19%) of Nutmeg are lower than Moneyfarm (0.25%). Hence, we can conclude that the trading fee of Nutmeg is lower than Moneyfarm for accounts above an estimated £236,000. Nutmeg is expensive when compared to other automated investment services such as Vanguard data funds (0.30%), Wealthfront (0.40%), Sigfee’s (£10 per month flat fee) and Betterment, which charges between 0.35% to 0.15% dependant on investment size. Though Nutmeg is expensive compared to some automated services, it offers more involvement by investment managers, thus making it a hybrid instrument for investors.

Cost Break up of Alternatives to Nutmeg Investment

Like Moneyfarm, Nutmeg has an easy-to-follow fee structure that rewards users who invest more on its platform. Following is the cost analysis of the top nutmeg investment alternatives available:

  • Hargreaves Lansdown: This is the UK’s largest broker and has clear and detailed information on every fund. It also provides tools to compare with peers. The firm charges 0.45% per year as administration charges on the fund selected by the client.
  • Tilney Bestinvest: This is one of the rival broker companies and it charges an annual fee for its services on top of the annual price clients pay to invest in the fund. Bestinvest charges 0.4% of the investment value as administration charges per year, with the client usually paying 0.75% for each fund.
  • Charles Stanley: If the biggest concern of a client is cost then Charles Stanley is the best choice as it charges low fees of 0.25% annually and offers research tools with investment trusts and funds.
  • Cavendish: Another cost-friendly broker house is Cavendish, as its cost is the same as Charles Stanley, but they don’t provide investment trusts. One of the key features of this company is that it does not charge any switching or exit fees, so clients will not be penalized.

If you are looking for bigger names, then Barclays and Axa Self Investor are good investment options. They levy a 0.35% annual charge which is comparable to the best stock broker firms in the UK.

Factors Influencing Nutmeg Investment

According to the Nutmeg website, in the past two years the company was able to generate around £1.9 million in savings for their customers. Following are the factors which should influence an investor in making a final decision whether to put his or her business with Nutmeg or find some Nutmeg investment alternatives:

  • Availability in the UK: Nutmeg investment is only available to UK customers.
  • Initial investment: Nutmeg requires an initial investment of £500 per fund for set-up and is currently available for retail customers only. The cost to manage funds is quite low compared to other broker firms.
  • Investment portfolios: Nutmeg is a low-cost investment company which provides around ten investment portfolios for customers. Each portfolio is a mix of investment assets. Clients have a choice to select a fully managed or fixed allocation portfolio based on their appetite for risk.
  • Nutmeg Investment offering: Nutmeg offers investment in stocks and shares ISAs, which are tailored based on risk profile. They also offer a Nutmeg pension product and a Nutmeg lifetime ISA. Nutmeg investment also provides new investors with the ability to set up funds like a pension fund, a Nutmeg ISA and LISA very quickly.
  • Nutmeg Investment performance: As per the Asset Risk consulting company, Nutmeg has performed well compared to competitors. It was observed that initial returns were not high but over the long-term Nutmeg investments exceeded expectations and managed to secure a 58-75% return in an eight-to-ten-year time frame

How Safe is Nutmeg Investment?

There have been several reviews and some press coverage regarding the fact that Nutmeg has yet to turn a profit. The company lost £9 million in 2016 and attributed that loss to rising costs, technology upgrades and holding clients’ money rather than paying another company to do so. But clients should not worry, as investments are kept in the custodial bank (a specialized institution responsible for keeping clients’ investments secure) in order to safeguard the investment. Since client assets are kept separate from Nutmeg assets, in the case of insolvency or failure, clients’ money is secured from such adverse external factors.

Nutmeg also provides coverage through the Financial Services Compensation Scheme, which shields investments up to £50,000. Also, Nutmeg has just reached £1 billion AUM (Assets Under Management) and according to statistics of robo advisor companies, the £1 billion mark is the break-even point for any company to make profits. Since Nutmeg believes in diversifying capital across a range of global assets, it mitigates the risk of overindulgence in one particular sector and also rebalances portfolios periodically to ensure high returns with investment goals. Nutmeg rates security as a key factor and has industry standard security. One thing to note is that the composition of assets in a portfolio is selected by the Nutmeg team, and like other robo advisors Nutmeg investment uses ETF to track indices like the FTSE 100. Investors are mapped accordingly based on risk appetite.

Funding and Awards

Since the company’s inception in 2011 it has won numerous awards. In November 2016 Nutmeg raised £30 million from Convoy and existing investing including Balderton Capital, Armada Investment Group, Pentech and Nigel Wray. After one month Nutmeg attracted an additional £12 million from Taipei Fubon Bank. Those funds are being used for innovation and expansion of the company. In 2017 Nutmeg also partnered with Fidor, an online challenger bank, for fintech services. In November 2016 Nutmeg revealed that it manages approximately £600 million assets on behalf of around 25,000 clients. In the first six months of 2017, Nutmeg’s client base doubled from 20,000 to 45,000, and assets under management surged from £600 million to £900 million. Nutmeg also provides stocks and shares ISAs, which are a tax-efficient way of investing in the stock market as gains are tax free and there is an option to divide the amount across stocks, shares ISAs, cash ISAs or lifetime ISAs. In September 2017 the company revealed that, based on five years of data, their portfolios have outperformed those of their peers due to the reduced costs. Following are a few awards the company has won:

  • The Your Money award in 2015 and 2016 from Best Online Stocks and Shares
  • Best ETF Advisor and Best Robo Advisor in 2016 from ETF.com Awards
  • Overall winner of innovation in financial sector in 2016 from the Fstech Awards
  • In 2014 Nutmeg received Euromoney Awards, Good Web Guide Awards and Ecommerce Awards for Excellence

guide trading

Customer Support and Robust Mobile Nutmeg App

Nutmeg is a robo advisor and online discretionary investment company. In order to open a new account, clients must answer a series of questions related to their investment goals and attitude toward risk. Based on their answers Nutmeg will assign a unique strategy based on algorithms to the prospective investor. Based on that strategy the company will build a portfolio which will include products such as equities, cash, bonds and real estate.

Another factor which influences investors is customer support. Nutmeg customer care is based in the UK and provides live chat, email and phone support from 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m., Monday through Friday. Response time by email is generally one to two days, and the customer can log a ticket via email in case a service representative is not available by phone. According to some Nutmeg reviews, in the majority of cases service agents were able to resolve customer queries and did not require repeated follow-ups.

No investment company is complete without offering mobile apps for their customers. Nutmeg has free apps for both iOS and Nutmeg android. These apps are specially designed to check asset performance and to keep track of ISA allowances, topping up of the portfolio and to set regular payments. The overall rating of the Nutmeg app is 4.1 on Google Play, and around 45,000 investors across the UK are associated with Nutmeg through their investments portfolio.

1
of 21 Forex Broker Cityindex
Currency pairs 84 Currencies
Max. Lever 1:30
Trading size Mini-Lot
Minimum deposit € 100
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
2
of 21 Forex Broker Pepperstone
Currency pairs 70 Currencies
Max. Lever 1:30
Trading size Mini-Lot
Minimum deposit $ 200
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
3
of 21 Forex Broker Markets.com
Currency pairs 50 Currencies
Max. Lever 1:30
Trading size Micro-Lot
Minimum deposit $ 100
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
4
of 21 Forex Broker AvaTrade
Currency pairs 47 Currencies
Max. Lever 1:30
Trading size Micro-Lot
Minimum deposit $ 100
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
5
of 21 Forex Broker Plus500
Currency pairs 61 Currencies
Max. Lever 1:30
Trading size Micro-Lot
Minimum deposit $ 100
Go to Broker
CFD Service. 80.6% lose money
1
of 6 ETF Broker Charles Stanley Direct
ETFs w/ discount
Custody fee 0 GBP
Min. deposit £ 50
Trading from 11,50 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
2
of 6 ETF Broker Fidelity
ETFs w/ discount 93
Custody fee 0 GBP
Min. deposit £ 2.500
Trading from 25 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
3
of 6 ETF Broker AJ Bell Youinvest
ETFs w/ discount
Custody fee 0 GBP
Min. deposit £ 0.00
Trading from 1,50 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
4
of 6 ETF Broker Bestinvest
ETFs w/ discount 216
Custody fee 0.4% annually
Min. deposit £ 500
Trading from 0 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
5
of 6 ETF Broker DEGIRO
ETFs w/ discount 740
Custody fee 0 GBP
Min. deposit £ 0
Trading from 1,75 GBP + 0,004%
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
1
of 10 Stock Broker Charles Stanley Direct
National fees £ 11,50
Custody fee 0,25%
Intl. fees £ 11,50
Dep. Protection 50,000 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
2
of 10 Stock Broker Fidelity
National fees £ 10,00
Custody fee 0,35%
Intl. fees £ 10,00
Dep. Protection 50,000 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
3
of 10 Stock Broker Bestinvest Brokerage
National fees £ 7,50
Custody fee 0,4%
Intl. fees £ 7,50
Dep. Protection 50,000 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
4
of 10 Stock Broker DEGIRO
National fees £ 1,75 + 0,004%
Custody fee £ 0,00
Intl. fees 0,50 € + 0,004%
Dep. Protection 20,000 €
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
5
of 10 Stock Broker IG Stock
National fees £ 8,00
Custody fee £ 8,00
Intl. fees 10 EUR
Dep. Protection 50,000 GBP
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
1
of 20 CFD Broker Markets.com
FTSE spread 1.5 Points
Dep. Protection € 20.000
Max. Lever 1:30
Min. deposit £ 100
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
2
of 20 CFD Broker AvaTrade
FTSE spread 1.5 Points
Dep. Protection € 50.000
Max. Lever 1:30
Min. deposit € 250
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
3
of 20 CFD Broker Pepperstone
FTSE spread 1 Point
Dep. Protection £ 50000
Max. Lever 1:30
Min. deposit $ 200
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
4
of 20 CFD Broker Plus500
FTSE spread Variable
Dep. Protection £ 50.000
Max. Lever 1:30
Min. deposit £ 100
Go to Broker
CFD Service. 80.6% lose money
5
of 20 CFD Broker City Index
FTSE spread 1.0 Point
Dep. Protection £ 50.000
Max. Lever 1:30
Min. deposit £ 100
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
1
of 14 Crypto Broker IG
Crypto currencies 6
Max. Lever 1:2
Min. deposit £ 250
BTC spread 65 points
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
2
of 14 Crypto Broker IQ Option
Crypto currencies 13
Max. Lever 1:1
Min. deposit $ 100
BTC spread 6 percent
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
3
of 14 Crypto Broker CC Trader Crypto
Crypto currencies 5
Max. Lever 1:1
Min. deposit € 0
BTC spread 0
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
4
of 14 Crypto Broker City Index
Crypto currencies 5
Max. Lever 1:2
Min. deposit £ 0
BTC spread 40
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
5
of 14 Crypto Broker Markets.com
Crypto currencies 5
Max. Lever 1:2
Min. deposit $ 100
BTC spread 140 Points
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
1
of 6 Social Trading Broker ZuluTrade
Underlying assets 0
Dep. Protection 0
Min. deposit € 0
Max. Lever 1:30
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
2
of 6 Social Trading Broker eToro
Underlying assets 866
Dep. Protection 50000
Min. deposit $ 200
Max. Lever 1:30
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
3
of 6 Social Trading Broker Ayondo
Underlying assets 90
Dep. Protection 1000000
Min. deposit £ 2000
Max. Lever 1:30
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
4
of 6 Social Trading Broker Tradeo
Underlying assets 122
Dep. Protection 20000
Min. deposit £ 250
Max. Lever 1:30
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
5
of 6 Social Trading Broker FXTM
Underlying assets 247
Dep. Protection 20000
Min. deposit £ 5
Max. Lever 1:30
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
1
of 9 Spread Betting Broker City Index
FTSE spread 1 Point
Dep. Protection 50000
Max. Lever 1:20
Min. deposit £ 100
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
2
of 9 Spread Betting Broker IG
FTSE spread 1 Point
Dep. Protection 50000
Max. Lever 1:30
Min. deposit £ 0
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
3
of 9 Spread Betting Broker Core Spreads
FTSE spread 0.8 Points
Dep. Protection 50000
Max. Lever 1:30
Min. deposit £ 10
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
4
of 9 Spread Betting Broker OANDA
FTSE spread 1 Point
Dep. Protection 50000
Max. Lever 1:30
Min. deposit £ 0
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.
5
of 9 Spread Betting Broker GKFX
FTSE spread 0.9 Points
Dep. Protection 50000
Max. Lever 1:30
Min. deposit £ 20
Go to Broker
Risk warning: Capital can be lost. Terms and conditions apply.

Conclusion:

Nutmeg – Our Verdict

Nutmeg was created by Nick Hungerford and is known to provide one of the best online investment portfolio and robo advisory services. It provides one of the cheapest online investment services for clients looking to experts to manage their portfolios and make investment decisions on their behalf. Nutmeg provides decent returns for its clients and has outperformed many of its competitors with a comparatively high-risk portfolio. Nutmeg is known to provide competitive services with user-friendly tools and quality customer service. Low-cost fixed allocation portfolios are definitely going to attract clients who want peace of mind and don’t want to participate actively in the market. The only downside is that the Nutmeg minimum investment requirement may be high for certain investors. The fees charged on managed portfolios is also a bit high, but overall, Nutmeg’s stellar performance, simple and easy access to stocks and shares ISAs and a pension product with an excellent track record make it a winner.

Stocks Highlights