Commerzbank AG shares (ETR:CBK) slipped 1.89% to €33.77 during Thursday's German morning session, even as JPMorgan analyst Kian Abouhossein lifted the firm's price target on the stock to €36 from €33 while maintaining a Neutral rating.
The decline adds to a challenging start to 2026 for the Frankfurt-based lender, with shares now down 7.25% year-to-date, though the stock remains 88% higher over the past twelve months.
The muted market response to JPMorgan's raised price target reflects a broader shift in sentiment among analysts, who have increasingly expressed concern that Commerzbank's valuation has stretched following last year's remarkable rally. JPMorgan's decision to hold its Neutral stance, despite the higher target, underscores the view that much of the bank's turnaround story has already been priced into the shares.
A wave of downgrades from major financial institutions over recent months has reinforced this cautious positioning. JPMorgan Chase & Co. downgraded Commerzbank from Overweight to Neutral on September 9, 2025, acknowledging the bank's successful transformation while noting that upside potential now appears limited at current levels. Morgan Stanley followed suit on September 2, 2025, lowering its rating from Overweight to Equalweight despite raising its price target to €36, citing valuation concerns after the stock's substantial appreciation.
Goldman Sachs took an even more bearish view, downgrading Commerzbank from Neutral to Sell on August 27, 2025, with a price target of €34.10. The firm pointed to demanding valuations despite anticipated profitability improvements. Deutsche Bank also joined the chorus, moving from Buy to Hold on August 18, 2025, and raising its price target to €35 while expressing concern that the stock trades at a premium relative to the banking sector.
The string of downgrades comes as markets digest the implications of UniCredit SpA's aggressive stake-building in Commerzbank. The Italian banking group increased its position to approximately 28% in December 2024, a move the German government characterized as uncoordinated and hostile. This development has introduced a layer of uncertainty regarding Commerzbank's strategic independence and future direction, potentially weighing on near-term sentiment.
Counterbalancing these concerns, S&P Global Ratings revised its outlook on Commerzbank to positive from stable on December 4, 2025, while affirming its ‘A/A-1' long- and short-term issuer credit ratings. The ratings agency cited meaningful progress toward the bank's 2028 financial targets, including enhanced risk-adjusted profitability and improved resilience to unexpected stress scenarios.
Bull Case:
- JPMorgan raised its price target to €36, indicating belief in a higher fundamental value.
- The stock has demonstrated strong momentum, rising 88% over the past twelve months.
- S&P Global Ratings revised its outlook to positive, affirming the bank's progress toward its 2028 financial targets and enhanced resilience.
- Despite rating changes, multiple banks, including Morgan Stanley and Deutsche Bank, have recently increased their price targets.
Bear Case:
- The stock is facing near-term headwinds, down 7.25% year-to-date.
- A consensus is forming among analysts that the stock's valuation is stretched after its significant rally.
- Several major banks, including JPMorgan, Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, and Deutsche Bank, have recently downgraded their ratings on the stock.
- Strategic uncertainty exists due to UniCredit's aggressive and “hostile” stake-building, which could impact the bank's independence.
The divergence between raised price targets and downgraded ratings illustrates the challenge facing Commerzbank shares at current levels. While analysts recognize the bank's operational improvements and strategic progress, the stock's 88% surge over the past year has compressed the risk-reward equation. Markets appear to be taking a wait-and-see approach, with today's decline suggesting that further gains may require either stronger-than-expected financial performance or greater clarity on the UniCredit situation before sentiment can shift decisively positive.
Searching for the Perfect Broker?
Discover our top-recommended brokers for trading stocks, forex, cryptos, and beyond. Dive in and test their capabilities with complimentary demo accounts today!
- eToro Wide range of instruments available to trade – Read our Review
- Vantage High levels of account and deposit protection – Read our Review
- XTB UK regulated by the FCA – Read our Review
YOUR CAPITAL IS AT RISK. 76% OF RETAIL CFD ACCOUNTS LOSE MONEY
