Skip to content

UnitedHealth Sues US Government Over Star Ratings

UnitedHealth, the largest Medicare Advantage insurer, has sued the US government. It says regulators wrongly calculated its 2027 star ratings on 45 contracts, putting government bonus payments at risk.

UnitedHealth Group (NYSE: UNH), the largest US Medicare Advantage insurer, has sued the US government over its 2027 star ratings. The complaint was filed late on Thursday. It says regulators wrongly calculated ratings on 45 contracts.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the federal agency that sets the ratings, improperly used 26 measures to calculate them, UnitedHealth alleges. It says CMS lacked statutory authority, gave it no chance to object, or both. Corrected ratings would be 0.5 to 1.5 stars higher, the company claims.

“We did not take this step lightly,” UnitedHealth said in a statement. “We remain committed to working with CMS to modernize the Stars program and create a more durable approach to measuring quality.”

Star ratings are government quality scores from one to five. Higher-rated plans earn bonus payments, and UnitedHealth says the ratings threaten imminent harm by depriving it of those payments and lowering patient benefits. In the complaint it calls them the government’s “principal signal” of plan quality to patients.

UnitedHealth had about 7.61 million Medicare Advantage patients at 30 September, according to its latest quarterly report, and a 30% market share, according to the American Medical Association.

It is not the first insurer to sue. CVS Health, parent of Aetna, filed in October and said it could lose more than $2 billion in bonus payments and rebate retention. Humana sued in 2024.

Separately, UnitedHealth shares closed at $339.85 on Friday 20 November, against $407.46 a week earlier, a weekly fall of about 16.6%. The week’s low was $324.67.

UNH.US
Line chart of UnitedHealth weekly share price from June to November 2026 showing a sharp drop in the latest week.
UnitedHealth weekly closing prices, June to 20 November 2026.

Both the UnitedHealth and CVS cases are before US District Judge Lisa Godbey Wood in Brunswick, Georgia. In May she ruled CMS had calculated Clover Health’s rating incorrectly and ordered a recalculation.

Asktraders News Team
Asktraders News Team
Team Member

The AskTraders Analyst Team features experts in technical and fundamental analysis, as well as traders specializing in stocks, forex, and cryptocurrency.

Stay ahead of the markets

Sign up to our free Morning Markets email, every weekday before the open.