mwb Research said in a new note that BASF (ETR: BAS) made the right decision in abandoning its pursuit of Evonik (ETR: EVK).
The firm reiterated its Hold rating and 55 euro price target on the German chemicals group.
BASF ended its efforts to acquire Evonik after its rival rejected two non-binding, all-cash offers. BASF had been prepared to raise its 24 euros-per-share offer moderately.
However, mbb noted that Evonik’s lack of meaningful engagement and BASF’s own view of the company’s standalone prospects left little reason to pay more.
“We think BASF is right to walk away, particularly as we had become increasingly concerned that the acquisition price would cap shareholder value creation,” analyst Abed Jarad wrote.
Jarad said the industrial logic was credible. Folding Evonik into BASF’s Verbund system, in which interconnected plants share energy, raw materials and byproducts, could have improved the economics of its European production network.
However, he questioned whether putting more capital into a structurally disadvantaged region was the right priority. Employment commitments would also have limited how much restructuring, and therefore how many savings, BASF could achieve.
“We would much rather see BASF preserve its financial flexibility and capacity for shareholder distributions at a time when endmarket demand remains structurally weak and cash generation continues to lag earnings,” he added.
The firm believes BASF has enough recovery potential within its existing business without large-scale deals. It expects restructuring, portfolio changes, lower capital spending and a growing contribution from its new site in Zhanjiang, China, to support earnings and cash flow into 2027 and 2028.
However, mwb believes a re-rating of the stock would require a genuine recovery in customer demand. That would let volume growth drive earnings beyond cost-cutting and temporary pricing gains.
“At current levels, we believe the share price adequately reflects both the recovery potential and the remaining risks,” Jarad added.
