Muddy Waters Research, an activist short seller, said on Tuesday that it is short Nvidia (NASDAQ: NVDA), the maker of GPU chips used in AI computing. A short is a bet that the share price will fall, so the firm has a financial interest in the shares falling.
Its report rests on one question rather than on a valuation case or price target. Muddy Waters asks whether a woman photographed with a recently departed senior Nvidia executive is the same person as a former executive at Super Micro Computer (SMCI), which builds servers that use Nvidia GPUs.
The starting point is a class action, a lawsuit brought on behalf of a group of shareholders, filed against Super Micro in October. Muddy Waters says the complaint alleges that Cenly Chen, the company’s former Chief Growth Officer, ran its purchasing of Nvidia GPUs and decided which customers received them.
Muddy Waters also cites the indictment in March of three Super Micro employees in the US. It says they illegally sold at least about $2.5bn of Super Micro servers containing Nvidia GPUs to end customers in China through a Singapore front company. The complaint, as quoted by Muddy Waters, goes on to say:
no way Cenly Chen lacked knowledge of [SMCI’s] illicit sales.
Class action complaint against Super Micro Computer
Muddy Waters says a woman identified as Cenly Chen, and as Cenly Puri in some photograph tags, was photographed in public between 2024 and 2026 with Ajay K. Puri. Until late June he was Nvidia’s EVP Worldwide Field Operations and, in Muddy Waters’ judgement, likely its third most senior executive, behind Jensen Huang and Colette Kress.
Mr. Puri was one of five Nvidia executives named in the 2026 proxy, the annual shareholder-meeting filing naming executives and pay. Muddy Waters says his total pay in fiscal years 2024 to 2026 was slightly above Ms. Kress’. He left Nvidia in late June and remains a senior adviser, while the former Super Micro executive left that company in late April or early May.
Muddy Waters states that nobody named Cenley Chen has been indicted or otherwise accused of criminal conduct by any government, and that the class action allegations are unproven. The open question is whether the woman photographed with Mr. Puri is the same Cenly Chen formerly employed by Super Micro.
